• View
  • Changes
  • Options
  • Related
  • Edit
  • Just weighed in on the conversation at Aikido Journal about writings attributed to Morihei Ueshiba http://www.aikidojournal.com/blog/2011/03/03/o-senseis-spiritual-writings-where-did-they-really-come-from-by-stanley-pranin/.

     

    My comment:

     

    Thanks again for your faithful ongoing work in clarifying where literal history intersects with the interpretation of ideas associated with aikido. In my experience, there are often very different expectations when professional martial artists and professional scholars end up in the same conversation (or even in the same personality).

     

    I sometimes see martial artists presupposing that truth can only be found in simplicity of expression (perhaps “either he said these words or he didn’t - which is it?”), whereas those accustomed to treating language critically have been trained to assume that any use of language is a complex of meanings (literal, figurative, factual, imaginal) which second hand transmission and translation make even more problematic.

     

    It has been my delight to discover in many martial artists one particular virtue that applies here, and from which scholars certainly benefit. That is the assumption that, while helpful ideas may come from many sources, there is only one place to receive communication with certain provenance, and that is the mouth of the person claiming the ideas involved. Even so, any speaker, no matter how precise, makes mythology: an imaginative way of cultivating understanding and building systems through language with enough room for the full range of both fact and fiction.

     

    your laboratory and library for working co-creatively with the mythologies and psychologies that shape our world.


    Culturesmith_button_02b-medium-48055

    Please click on the graphic above to contribute new content.


    About Brandon WilliamsCraig Ph.D.

    Menu+image-small-5490

    Professional Materials

    Online Training &

    Academic Syllabi

    Associative Inquiry

    Peace Practices

    Martial Nonviolence

    Free Aiki Dojo

    Golden Bears Aikido

    Process Arts

    The Myth of Peace


    members. Please sign in, or apply to be a member to access more in-depth content. Click an arrow > to open enbedded cards. Need help?


    For those with whom I have a payment agreement, please enter the maximum amount you want to pay each month and then click the button below. Then Sign in to pay with your PayPal account or click where it says "No PayPal account? Pay using your credit or debit card"
    $ USD
    Sign up for


    Twitter

    Delicious


     

    Content and design copyright Brandon WilliamsCraig ~ Wheeled by Wagn v. 1.8.1